Business executives analyzing a carve-out strategy for selling a corporate division

Corporate Carve-Out in Spain: A Real-World Case Study (€3.2M Deal)

Fundenza

A real-world case study of how a Spanish industrial group executed a carve-out and sold its logistics division for €3.2M: deal structure, asset separation, valuation methodology, mistakes made, and lessons learned.

A carve-out is one of the least understood M&A transactions among European business owners — and yet it can be the most effective way to unlock value within a business group. Selling the entire company is not always the right answer: sometimes, a specific division is worth significantly more in the hands of a different buyer than it is as part of a larger group. This article walks through a real-world case study — with details modified to preserve confidentiality — to show how a carve-out is structured, valued, and executed in practice.

What Is a Carve-Out and When Does It Make Sense?

A carve-out means separating and selling a business unit, subsidiary, or division of a larger company, while the owner retains control of the remaining business. This is not a full exit: the seller stays in charge of the core business and receives liquidity only for the portion divested.

A carve-out makes strategic sense when:

  • A division has grown to have a commercial life of its own, and a strategic buyer would pay more for it than its contribution to the consolidated group.
  • The group needs cash to invest in its core business without taking on new debt.
  • Two businesses within the same holding company have such different models that the market undervalues them when bundled together — the so-called conglomerate discount.
  • A loss-making division absorbs management bandwidth and financial resources from the profitable core.
  • The founder wants partial liquidity without fully exiting the business.

In Spain and across Europe, carve-outs have gained momentum since 2022, driven by rising debt costs and pressure from private equity sponsors to streamline portfolios. Industrial family-owned groups with revenues between €10M and €50M have been the most active sellers in this segment.

The Case Study: METALFAB Sells Its Logistics Division

METALFAB (a pseudonym) is an industrial group headquartered in Valencia, Spain, manufacturing metal components for the automotive sector. Twelve years ago, to control costs and delivery lead times, the group set up an internal logistics subsidiary we'll call LOGIFAB. Over time, LOGIFAB began serving third-party clients: by 2024, 40% of its revenue came from customers outside the group, underpinned by fifteen recurring annual contracts.

The Trigger: An Unsolicited Approach

METALFAB's CEO received a call from a national logistics operator with a presence in ten Spanish provinces. The informal offer was €2.8 million for 100% of LOGIFAB. The figure came as a pleasant surprise: the management team had valued the division internally at around €1.5 million, based on book value.

The gap between the two figures was a clear signal: someone saw considerably more value in LOGIFAB than the group was attributing internally. Before responding, METALFAB engaged an M&A advisor. The first strategic decision was not to accept the offer directly, but to run a controlled competitive process with two or three additional potential buyers. The final sale price was €3.2 million — 14% above the best opening bid.

Operational Separation: The Hardest Part of Any Carve-Out

This is where most time and money is spent in a carve-out — and where processes stall or fail if poorly managed. LOGIFAB was not a clean subsidiary: it shared warehouses, vehicle fleet, insurance contracts, ERP software, and four cross-functional employees with the parent company.

The separation work included:

  1. Asset inventory: identifying which vehicles, storage facilities, and equipment were exclusive to LOGIFAB versus shared with METALFAB, and assigning market values to each.
  2. Carve-out accounts: preparing financial statements for LOGIFAB as if it had operated independently for the past three years. This was the single most expensive task in the process (€38,000 in external audit fees).
  3. Transitional Services Agreement (TSA): METALFAB agreed to continue providing LOGIFAB with admin, payroll, and IT services for 18 months post-closing, at cost plus a 5% margin.
  4. Contract segregation: third-party client contracts were formally assigned to LOGIFAB as an independent entity; intragroup contracts were novated or terminated by mutual agreement.
  5. Employee realignment: the four cross-functional employees had to choose which entity to join; METALFAB offered a one-off payment to those who moved to LOGIFAB with the sale.

The separation process took four months — twice the two months initially budgeted — and cost approximately €85,000 in legal, accounting, and advisory fees. An investment that paid back many times over in the final price achieved.

Valuation: Why the Market Paid Double the Book Value

The gap between the internal book valuation (€1.5M) and the market price (€3.2M) reflects three factors that accounting alone cannot capture:

  • Buyer-specific synergies: the winning bidder could integrate LOGIFAB into its national network, spreading fixed costs over a significantly larger revenue base. The value to the buyer exceeded LOGIFAB's standalone intrinsic value.
  • Established third-party revenue: the 40% of revenue from external clients represented recurring, METALFAB-independent income. This was the asset buyers weighted most heavily in their valuation models.
  • Competitive process discipline: having multiple buyers at the table created pricing tension. The winner paid 14% above its opening offer to outbid a competing party.

The final transaction multiple was 5.8x normalised EBITDA — above the Spanish logistics sector average of 4.5–5.0x for deals of this size in 2024.

Key Lessons: What Worked and What Cost Money

Three decisions explain the success of this carve-out:

  • Not accepting the first offer. The instinct to close quickly would have cost €400,000. Running a process, even when it slows things down, creates measurable value.
  • Investing in operational separation upfront. Presenting a "clean" LOGIFAB with standalone financial statements and no undocumented dependencies reduced perceived risk for buyers and eliminated downward price adjustments in the SPA.
  • Negotiating a well-structured TSA. Buyers would not have paid the same price if they had to absorb operational continuity risk from day one.

Mistakes that cost time and money:

  • Underestimating separation timelines: two months planned; four months actual. This delayed closing and required renegotiating certain LOI terms when the initial exclusivity period expired.
  • Failing to anticipate impact on the core business's customer relationships: several of METALFAB's industrial clients were unsettled by the news of the logistics sale. Proactive communication and, in some cases, pricing adjustments were needed to retain contracts.

The Five Phases of a Well-Executed Carve-Out

  1. Strategic decision and preliminary valuation: before approaching any buyers, the seller must understand the intrinsic value of the unit to be carved out, the cost of the separation, and the value proposition for potential acquirers.
  2. Operational separation and carve-out preparation: map assets, contracts, employees, and systems. Prepare carve-out accounts. Design the TSA if required.
  3. M&A process: prepare the information memorandum, identify and contact potential buyers, execute NDAs, and collect indicative offers.
  4. Due diligence and SPA negotiation: buyers will audit the unit as a standalone business. Audited or at minimum externally reviewed carve-out accounts are non-negotiable.
  5. Closing and transition: sign the sale and purchase agreement, transfer assets, complete employee reassignment, and activate the TSA.

Carve-Out vs. Full Company Sale: When to Choose Each

The choice between selling the entire group and executing a carve-out depends on three questions:

  • Is the part worth more than its contribution to the whole? If strategic buyers would pay a higher multiple for the division than the market would apply to the consolidated group, a carve-out creates net value.
  • Does the core business improve without the division? Sometimes, divesting a division that consumes management attention or working capital allows the group to focus and grow faster.
  • Does the founder want to continue running the core business? A carve-out delivers partial liquidity without full exit — an option worth considering when the owner is not ready for a full sale.

Frequently Asked Questions About Carve-Outs

How long does a carve-out take from decision to closing?

Between 9 and 18 months, depending on the complexity of the operational separation. Divisions that are deeply integrated with the parent company typically sit at the longer end of that range.

What are carve-out accounts and why do they matter?

Carve-out accounts are financial statements that present the divested unit as if it had operated as a standalone entity for the past three to four years. Buyers need them to run their valuation models and due diligence. Without credible, well-documented carve-out accounts, the process drags and pricing is typically adjusted downward.

Is a TSA necessary in every carve-out?

Not always, but very common when the carved-out unit relied on shared group services — IT, administration, HR, facilities. A well-negotiated TSA protects the buyer during the transition period and allows the seller to charge market rates for those services.

How are employees affected by a carve-out?

In Spain, Article 44 of the Workers' Statute provides that employees transfer to the new employer while retaining their existing terms and conditions. The process requires formal notification to employee representatives, which should be planned well in advance of the transaction announcement.

Can private equity funds acquire carve-out businesses?

Yes — this is common when the carved-out unit has revenues above €5–8M and standalone growth potential. Private equity sponsors are particularly active buyers in carve-outs from family-owned groups looking to redeploy capital into their strategic core.

How much is your company worth?

Get a free indicative valuation in under 2 minutes. No commitment, fully confidential.

Value my company for free